Welcome back to your latest dose of Wandernests Dispatch – where brand brilliance meets hidden adventures and meals that linger long after the last bite. If your week needs some fuel, Dispatch 3 has just dropped.
Think smarter branding, subterranean magic and wood-fired pizza heaven. First, we see how L’Oréal is rewriting its growth playbook with tech and personalisation. Then, we slip beneath Krakow’s streets into a salt mine where silence is sacred. And finally, we taste ‘Little Italy’ in Amsterdam, where pizza, cocktails and golden hour meet.
A perch for marketing insights, brand thinking, and cultural trends – from someone who’s spent decades on both the client and agency sides, and now works at the intersection of brand strategy and marketing transformation at global consultancy. If you’re curious about brand-building, storytelling or the changing face of marketing, this is your nest.
L’Oréal’s secret? Marketing that behaves more like a matchmaker than a megaphone. Forget vanity campaigns – L’Oréal’s growth engine now runs on data, personalization and tech that actually understands people. This piece unpacks how the beauty giant is reinventing marketing to feel less mass and more made-for-you.
A journal of journeys – near and far. Expect detailed itineraries, thoughtful travel tips and hacks, and reflections from around the world that go beyond the bucket list. I write as a traveler, not a tourist -curious, observant, and always seeking connection. Scenic detours, soulful cities and tried-and-tested itineraries for your next adventure.
Forget crowded squares – the magic of Krakow hides underground. This story plunges you into 700 years of salt-carved chapels, legends and hushed reflections in subterranean lakes, where silence feels sacred and light dances off rock salt walls.
A celebration of all things food and lifestyle. Recipes that anchor memory, honest restaurant finds that pack an unexpected burst of flavor and surprise, and stories of kitchens across the world that reveal more than just what’s on the plate. All rooted in a love for good taste, not trends. From comfort food to culinary trails, dive into recipes, reviews and flavor notes rooted in good tastes.
If flavours were a GPS, it’d lead you straight to La Perla. Skip the touristy pizza parlours – La Perla is where wood-fired dough, molten mozzarella and authentic Italian heat converge in Amsterdam’s Jordaan. This piece takes you through a golden-hour bank holiday feast that tastes like ‘Little Italy’ in every bite.
This summer, two very different brands – Carl’s Jr. and Bud Light – quietly swapped inclusive, socially conscious messaging for tried-and-tested Americana. Out went the bold purpose-led marketing statements. In came BBQs, bikinis, and backyard banter. ‘Safe’ advertising is back. And it’s not just them.
Unilever, long heralded as the godfather of purpose-led marketing, has officially backpedaled. CEO Hein Schumacher told investors the company would no longer ‘force-fit’ purpose into every brand, citing dilution and backlash risks. Instead, only brands with credible, commercially-aligned purpose would continue on that path.
Welcome to the new era of purpose fatigue – where cultural polarisation, consumer blowback, and performance pressure are colliding to make even the most confident marketers pause.
– Consumer polarisation is real: FCB & Angus Reid found political views now strongly influence purchases, pushing leaders toward cautious, middle-of-the-road campaigns.
– Purpose is becoming diluted: Unilever’s CEO Hein Schumacher recently admitted the company would no longer ‘force-fit’ purpose into every brand – citing risk of overextension, weak ROI, and shareholder pushback.
– Backlash risk is high: Pride sponsorships and DEI ads are increasingly being pulled at the last minute – driven by legal, shareholder, or political concerns.
🔥 The Brand Balancing Act
Let’s not forget: the past decade has been shaped by brands ‘taking a stand’. Nike, Patagonia, Dove – they all taught marketers that values could drive value.
But 2025 tells a different story.
At Cannes Lions this year, marketers debated whether brand bravery had become brand liability. On one side, advocates calling for brands to hold their ground. On the other, risk officers, CFOs and comms leads pulling the emergency brake.
🟠 Retreating from Purpose:
Carl’s Jr., once known for purpose-led campaigns, reverted to nostalgia (“burgers and bikinis”) in its Super Bowl spot.
Bud Light shifted to BBQ-and-beer ads after DEI backlash, prioritising broad appeal over cause association.
Unilever is strategically retracting from sweeping purpose commitments – streamlining focus on fewer, more financially meaningful initiatives.
🟢 Doubling down on Purpose:
Nespresso, post-pressure, has embraced ‘brand-led transparency’ – earning B Corp certification and embedding ESG into purpose-driven storytelling.
Ben & Jerry’s, under Unilever, is bucking the trend – releasing ‘Make Some Motherchunkin’ Change’ on racial justice and climate. This campaign isn’t just messaging; it’s a brand-defining stance that’s generating high consumer engagement and loyalty.
Patagonia, as ever, proves purpose pays – so long as it’s aligned with product, culture, and leadership DNA.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Wandernests – your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
⚔️ The CMO Dilemma: To Speak or Not to Speak
Brand leaders now find themselves in a bind. Consumers (especially Gen Z) still expect activism. But activist messaging, especially around DEI, is increasingly risky terrain. For every Dove that goes viral with a body positivity campaign, there’s a brand facing lawsuits, boycotts, or media firestorms.
And let’s not forget: many brands that once flew the Pride flag have quietly stepped back in 2025. According to Ad Age, several major advertisers have ‘reduced or removed’ LGBTQ+ visibility in their comms – without press releases or apologies. The silence is telling.
Purpose isn’t dead – but purpose for purpose’s sake is under attack. Strategic purpose only works when it’s both genuine and growth-relevant – not forced or merely symbolic.
Common Pitfall
Smarter Purpose Play
Forcing purpose across every SKU
Target purpose where it’s authentic and impactful
Retiring all social messaging
Use data-informed risk testing to pilot purpose campaigns
Siloed brand/ creative work
Align purpose messaging with product innovation and brand core
🤔 Questions to Spark Discussion
Is your brand’s purpose authentic, differentiated and defensible – even under scrutiny?
Which causes align with your business model and consumer promise, not trend-chasing?
Are you building consumer-led purpose journeys or broadcasting from the top?
What Comes Next?
CMOs are moving from purpose everywhere to purpose where it matters. Expect tighter guardrails, deeper internal alignment, and a stronger link between brand purpose and business performance.
✅ Authenticity over optics ✅ Product truth over purpose theatre ✅ Long-term consistency over campaign-of-the-moment
As one Cannes juror put it: ‘The era of lazy purpose is over. If it doesn’t link to what you make and how you behave – it’s not strategy, it’s stunt’.
In a deeply polarised world, playing it safe risks leading from the middle – where purpose fades. The brands that win won’t just stand for something – they’ll stand up strategically. Bold isn’t an option. It’s a necessity.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Wandernests – your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
By Wandernests Dispatch – Brand Nest I 14 July, 2025
The IPA Bellwether Report, now in its 25th year, is more than a quarterly pulse check on CMOs and their marketing spend. It’s a mirror held up to the industry – reflecting shifting priorities, rising pressures, and new possibilities.
As the IPA steps back to reflect on two and a half decades of data, the patterns aren’t just revealing. For marketers in the UK and Ireland (UKI), they sound a clear warning.
Beyond the headlines of spend upticks and downturns lies a deeper narrative. One marked by operating model upheavals, the delicate dance of global-local marketing, and the professionalisation of marketing capabilities. It also exposes a discipline still fighting for a seat at the boardroom table.
This isn’t just a retrospective. It’s a provocation – a call to shape what must come next.
1. Operating Models: From Mad Men to Modular Machines
A central thread emerging from the IPA’s longitudinal analysis is the shift from traditional brand-and-creative-led structures to highly integrated, tech-infused, modular marketing operating models.
Fast forward to the 2020s, and the landscape looks very different. Operating models have evolved into fluid ecosystems. These often include dotted-line relationships between in-house studios, performance partners, martech stacks, and global centres of excellence.
Key Insight: The report reveals that firms using hybrid operating models – blending in-house and outsourced capabilities – score higher on marketing effectiveness.
For UKI marketers, this raises a critical question: Is your operating model built for a world where content velocity, real-time optimisation, and cross-functional collaboration are non-negotiables?
Think of Wandernestsas your creative layover – where brand strategy takes a breather, recharges, and flies sharper. Got thoughts or want to co-pilot an idea? Write to us at editor@wandernests.com.
2. Global-Local Marketing: Rebalancing the Power Equation
The Bellwether findings subtly but consistently reflect a rebalancing act between global brand mandates and local market nuance. While globalisation pushed for message uniformity and efficiency, the most resilient brands in the dataset were those that invested in local insight, community-led execution, and culturally relevant activations.
Over the past decade, we’ve witnessed the rise of “glocal” marketing squads – global frameworks delivered with local agility. These models aim to strike a balance between consistency and contextual relevance.
Key Insight: The report reinforces the importance of operating models that enable local execution without sacrificing global coherence. UKI marketers, in particular, must avoid two extremes: passively localising global assets or over-investing in full localisation.
Instead, the focus should be on capability building – empowering local teams to adapt, interpret, and elevate global strategy, rather than simply translate it.
🧠 Spotted a marketing model that made you wince – or quietly applaud? Maybe you’ve wrestled with a global campaign that wouldn’t flex locally. Or sat in a budget meeting where brand got benched for clicks. We want to hear the war stories, the “we tried that once” confessions, and the unsung wins from the marketing trenches.
📩 Write to us at editor@wandernests.com 📣 Or share your take with #WandernestsDispatch – the more unfiltered, the better. Let’s compare scars, share survival strategies, and maybe even blueprint the next 25 years.
3. Budget Shifts: From Creative Glory to Performance Gravity
Perhaps the most glaring trend in the report is the migration of budgets from brand-building to performance marketing. As a result, digital spend overtook traditional channels in the mid-2010s, and has remained dominant. However, the data tells a more nuanced story.
Short-termism tends to spike during economic downturns – as seen in 2008 and again in 2020. However, brands that protected long-term brand investment recovered faster once the crisis passed.
As Les Binet and Peter Field have long argued – and as the Bellwether data now confirms – the 60/40 brand-to-performance rule remains a critical principle.
So what? UKI marketers must shift the budget conversation. It’s time to reframe marketing from a cost centre to a growth lever. That means investing in attribution models that connect upper-funnel spend to business outcomes, not just what’s easiest to measure.
One of the more sobering insights from the 25-year analysis is the persistent underinvestment in marketing capability development. Despite increased pressure to drive growth, prove ROI, and integrate tech, many organisations still lack structured learning programmes for marketers.
Where capability development has gained traction – particularly in digitally mature organisations – it has been shaped by three powerful forces:
The explosion of martech, and the urgent need to skill up
The breakdown of silos across marketing, sales, and IT
The growing demand for internal agency-style agility
For UKI marketers, especially in mid-sized businesses, this isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s a pressing call to professionalise the marketing function. That means moving beyond on-the-job osmosis and investing in formal training.
Focus areas? Data literacy, strategic storytelling, and channel orchestration – the building blocks of modern marketing effectiveness.
So What for UKI Marketers?
The IPA Bellwether 25-year retrospective acts as both a rear-view mirror and a roadmap. For marketers across the UK and Ireland, it’s a call to action.
✅ Audit Your Operating Model
Is it modular, flexible, and built for speed – or still anchored in 20th-century workflows?
✅ Champion Brand and Performance Together
Fight for budget allocation that balances short-term sales with long-term brand equity. The 60/40 rule isn’t just theory – it’s proven.
✅ Invest in People, Not Just Platforms
Martech without capability is just shelfware. Prioritise training in areas like data fluency, content strategy, and performance optimisation.
✅ Build Local Empowerment
Push for global frameworks that enable, not police, local market teams. Contextual agility drives relevance.
✅ Elevate Marketing’s Internal Role
Leverage IPA data to position marketing as a growth engine, not a cost line. The boardroom conversation starts with business impact.
Conclusion: Marketing’s Inflection Point
The past 25 years have seen marketing weather recessions, digital disruption, and pandemics. The next 25 will demand even more agility, influence, and introspection. For UKI marketers, the Bellwether Report is not just a chronicle of change – it’s a catalyst for transformation.
The choice is stark: adapt the model or be outpaced by it.
Are you rethinking your marketing operating model or capability roadmap? At Wandernests, we help global brands evolve their marketing engines for what’s next. Get in touch at editor@wandernests.com for bespoke consulting or subscribe to our newsletter for monthly insights.
Marketers are under pressure to stay relevant in a world where trends die overnight. As a result, brands are leaning into internet absurdity: meme drops, ironic partnerships, and chaos-first content.
This new wave has a name: “chronically online” marketing.
What does a ranch-scented lip balm really say about Burt’s Bees? Such collabs can erode carefully built brand associations.
2. Confusion and Disconnection
If customers need a press release to “get it,” the stunt may be too clever for its own good. Short-term buzz rarely equals long-term impact.
3. Loss of Trust and Authenticity
When a brand does something too off-brand, loyal customers may feel alienated. The result? Reduced brand trust – and brand fatigue.
🌀 Spotted a collab that made you do a double take – or double tap? We want to hear from you! Was it butter-scented perfume? Ketchup couture? A cereal brand launching NFTs? Whether you loved it, loathed it, or still can’t quite believe it happened, we’d love to hear the unhinged brand mashups that left a mark. 📩 Drop us a line at editor@wandernests.com 📸 Or tag your favourite (or most cursed) collabs using #WandernestsDispatch on Instagram or in the comments below. Let’s trade marketing war stories – over mismatched logos, collab chaos, and a limited-edition burger-scented candle. 🔥💬
When Wild Collaborations Actually Work
That said, not all unhinged collabs are missteps. Some manage to stay bold and on-brand.
Welcome back to the second edition of Wandernests Dispatch – your weekly passport to a bold brand insight, a soul-stirring escape, and a flavor-packed treat. If your Wednesday needed a kick-start, we’ve got you covered. Strap in – Dispatch No. 2 is serving bold flavors, sharper smarts, and a view worth the climb.
This week, we break down the future-proof skills every marketer needs (spoiler: Excel won’t save you), take a misty mountain detour to Montserrat’s sacred heights, and end with a Chinese feast where the soup dumplings burst and the flavors slap. Hard.
A perch for marketing insights, brand thinking, and cultural trends – from someone who’s spent decades on both the client and agency sides and now works at the intersection of brand strategy and marketing transformation at global consultancy. If you’re curious about brand-building, storytelling, or the changing face of marketing, this is your nest.
Forget flashy tools – the marketers of tomorrow will win with clarity, curiosity and the guts to experiment. This piece breaks down the skills that’ll actually matter when AI becomes the intern and data gets personal.
A journal of journeys – near and far. Expect detailed itineraries, thoughtful travel tips and hacks and reflections from around the world that go beyond the bucket list. I write as a traveler, not a tourist -curious, observant and always seeking connection. Scenic detours, soulful cities and tried-and-tested itineraries for your next adventure.
Photo by istockphoto.com I View of Montserrat Monastery perched atop the Catalan mountains near Barcelona, with stunning rock formations and surrounding greenery.
Ever hiked into a cathedral? Montserrat’s soaring cliffs and centuries-old basilica soundtracked by a 700‑year‑old boys’ choir will do just that. This story takes you from Barcelona’s bustle to misty mountaintops – where sacred song, surreal geology and Catalan magic collide.
A celebration of all things food and lifestyle. Recipes that anchor memory, honest restaurant finds that pack an unexpected burst of flavor and surprise and stories of kitchens across the world that reveal more than just what’s on the plate. All rooted in a love for good taste, not trends. From comfort food to culinary trails, dive into recipes, reviews and flavor notes rooted in good tastes.
Move over ramen – this isn’t just soup, it’s an art. We’re talking delicate, broth-soaked dumplings that burst in your mouth, paired with fresh-picked greens and sauces that won’t let go. One bite and you’ll agree: this Chinese feast doesn’t just fill you up – it drops jaws.
Enjoyed the read? Didn’t vibe with something else? We’re all ears. Reply to this email or drop us a note at editor@wandernests.com — we’d love to know what’s landing, what’s not, and what you want more of.
Early in How Brands Grow, Professor Sharp quotes Mark Twain’s observation that ‘Education consists mainly of what we have unlearned.’
By debunking conventional wisdom (those conventional marketing myths we know!) and backing every claim with hard data, Sharp forces marketers to confront uncomfortable truths. In this article summary, we break down the core marketing laws from Part 1 of the book – and illustrate each with real-world consumer packaged goods (CPG) examples. If you’re serious about brand growth, it’s time to rethink everything you thought you knew.
1. Growth Comes from Increasing Market Penetration, Not Loyalty
The Provocative Insight: Forget loyalty programs and CRM systems designed to deepen relationships with existing customers. Professor Sharp’s data proves: brands grow by acquiring more customers, not by increasing purchase frequency among a loyal few.
Gen AI Created Pic
CPG Case in Point: Coca-Cola Coca-Cola is a masterclass in penetration marketing. Rather than obsessing over loyalty cards or points, Coca-Cola invests in mass advertising, broad availability, and cultural relevance – from Olympic sponsorships to roadside kiosks in rural India. The result? A presence in nearly every fridge and vending machine on Earth.
Key Takeaway: Focus your marketing dollars on getting more people to buy once rather than convincing current buyers to buy more often.
2. All Brands Have Far More Light Buyers Than Heavy Ones
The Provocative Insight: The bulk of your revenue doesn’t come from die-hard fans but from casual, one-time or occasional buyers. Heavy buyers are not the growth engine – they’re a constant. Your biggest upside is increasing your reach among light and non-buyers.
Gen AI Created Pic
CPG Case in Point: Dove (Unilever) Dove doesn’t just market to skincare loyalists. Its “Real Beauty” campaign – launched in over 70 countries – was designed to emotionally resonate with everyone, especially those not actively buying beauty products. That strategy opened doors to first-time and light buyers, driving major market penetration and long-term growth.
Key Takeaway: Build mental and physical availability to attract light buyers. They’re the silent majority driving your business.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Brand Nest by Wandernests— your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
3. Double Jeopardy Law: Bigger Brands Have More Buyers and Higher Loyalty
The Provocative Insight: This isn’t karma; it’s maths. Bigger brands don’t just have more buyers – they also enjoy slightly higher loyalty because they’re more familiar and available. Loyalty is a function of penetration, not the other way around.
CPG Case in Point: Colgate Toothpaste Colgate has dominated the oral care aisle globally for decades – not just because of superior toothpaste, but because of consistent availability, brand salience, and distribution. Smaller players like Hello or Marvis may have intense niche loyalty, but Colgate’s mass reach gives it both scale and stickiness.
Key Takeaway: Don’t aim to “build loyalty” before you’ve built scale. Loyalty is a byproduct of mass penetration.
The Provocative Insight: Forget “USP.” Most buyers don’t notice subtle differences. What they do remember? Your logo, colour, jingle, mascot, or tagline. Sharp argues that distinctiveness, not differentiation, is what drives mental availability.
CPG Case in Point: Heinz Ketchup There are dozens of ketchup brands, many organic or cheaper. But Heinz owns the red keystone label, the glass bottle silhouette, and the unmistakable “57 varieties” claim. That’s distinctiveness—mental shortcuts that ensure recall at the shelf.
Key Takeaway: Focus on building a suite of distinctive brand assets—colours, logos, packaging—that help buyers recognize and recall you instantly.
The Provocative Insight: Brand growth depends on being easily thought of when buyers are in relevant purchase occasions. That means building broad, not deep, mental availability – across as many usage contexts, needs, and buyer types as possible.
Gen AI Created Pic
CPG Case in Point: Red Bull Red Bull has linked itself with a wide array of buying contexts: late-night studying, extreme sports, morning fatigue, clubbing. From Formula 1 to skydiving from space, its marketing constantly reinforces the “energy” association. It’s not deeper loyalty; it’s wider salience.
Key Takeaway: Your job is to create memory structures that increase the chance of your brand being recalled at the critical buying moment.
The Provocative Insight: You could have the best ad campaign in the world, but if your product isn’t available at the point of purchase, it’s worthless. Distribution matters as much as advertising – maybe more.
CPG Case in Point: Nestlé KitKat KitKat’s success in global markets isn’t due to its chocolate superiority. It’s down to omnipresence – from airports to rural kirana stores in India. When you’re everywhere, you get chosen more – simply because you’re there.
Key Takeaway: Maximise shelf presence, distribution reach, pack size variety, and channel ubiquity. Be easy to find and buy.
7. Don’t Over-Segment or Target Narrowly
The Provocative Insight: Sharp takes a hammer to traditional segmentation. He argues that most brand buyers don’t neatly fit into narrow psychographic or behavioral boxes. Over-targeting excludes vast swathes of potential buyers.
CPG Case in Point: NIVEA Instead of narrowly targeting “millennial women with dry skin,” NIVEA markets its body lotions to everyone. The brand’s success lies in its universal appeal, not hyper-targeting. One product, broad message, mass reach.
Key Takeaway: Ditch the obsession with targeting micro-segments. Mass marketing isn’t dead – it’s how brands grow.
8. Advertising’s Role: Refresh and Build Memory Structures
The Provocative Insight: Advertising isn’t about persuasion – it’s about salience. Good advertising builds and refreshes memory structures so the brand is top-of-mind in buying situations.
CPG Case in Point: Old Spice (Procter & Gamble) The now-iconic “Smell Like a Man, Man” campaign didn’t focus on features. It focused on being unforgettable, bizarre, and meme-worthy. That kept Old Spice relevant and memorable across generations.
Key Takeaway: Effective advertising doesn’t need to explain. It needs to make you easy to notice and hard to forget.
Final Thought: The Data Doesn’t Lie. But Marketers Often Do.
Byron Sharp’sHow Brands Grow isn’t just a critique of bad marketing habits – it’s a data-backed framework for building long-term growth. It challenges you to abandon myths around loyalty, differentiation, and targeting. The evidence is overwhelming: penetration wins, always.
If you’re a CPG marketer clinging to old-school funnels, niche targeting, or loyalty gimmicks – it’s time to upgrade your playbook. Your growth depends on it.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Brand Nest Dispatch by Wandernests— your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
Welcome to the very first edition of Wandernests Dispatch – where every Wednesday, we serve you a thoughtful morsel from each of our three nests: one brand provocation, one travel escape, and one delicious discovery. Think of it as a well-curated carousel of ideas, movement, and flavour – best enjoyed with coffee, curiosity, or both.
This week, we dive into fried chicken brand envy, sip our way through a whiskey-soaked walking tour and end with the kind of curry that makes a pub feel like a palace.
A perch for marketing insights, brand thinking, and cultural trends – from someone who’s spent decades on both the client and agency sides and now works at the intersection of brand strategy and marketing transformation at global consultancy. If you’re curious about brand-building, storytelling or the changing face of marketing, this is your nest.
A journal of journeys – near and far. Expect detailed itineraries, thoughtful travel tips and hacks and reflections from around the world that go beyond the bucket list. I write as a traveler, not a tourist -curious, observant and always seeking connection. Scenic detours, soulful cities and tried-and-tested itineraries for your next adventure.
A celebration of all things food and lifestyle. Recipes that anchor memory, honest restaurant finds that pack an unexpected burst of flavor and surprise and stories of kitchens across the world that reveal more than just what’s on the plate. All rooted in a love for good taste, not trends. From comfort food to culinary trails, dive into recipes, reviews and flavor notes rooted in good tastes.
By Wandernests Dispatch – Brand Nest I 23 May, 2025
The consumer packaged goods industry stands at a critical inflection point. One where data ownership for CPG brands has become the ultimate differentiator between market leaders and followers. As privacy regulations tighten and the cookieless future approaches, CPG brands face a stark choice. Take control of their customer data assets or remain dependent on agencies that may be holding their most valuable business intelligence hostage.
Leading brands like Coca-Cola, Unilever, and P&G have already made their choice, investing heavily in first-party data strategies that deliver personalized customer experiences, operational efficiency, and measurable competitive advantages. Ultimately, these CPG brands will own their consumer data longer-term. While those that don’t risk being locked into relationships that limit their strategic flexibility and growth potential.
The Data Ownership Crisis in CPG Marketing
The landscape of customer data ownership in consumer packaged goods brands has reached a tipping point that demands immediate attention from brand leaders.
The warning signs are becoming increasingly apparent across the industry. Agencies continue to employ tactics reminiscent of the early digital marketing era, claiming ownership of proprietary code and maintaining exclusive control over analytics accounts.
Therefore, making data transfer impossible when brands seek to change partnerships.
These practices effectively hold client data hostage, forcing brands into prolonged relationships even when performance fails to meet expectations or strategic needs evolve. The reality is that many CPG brands have inadvertently built their marketing intelligence on data foundations they do not own or control.
Why First-Party Data is the New Competitive Advantage
First-party data represents the most powerful competitive weapon available to CPG brands in today’s marketing landscape. Providing unparalleled insights that drive both immediate performance improvements and long-term strategic advantages. Unlike third-party data sources that offer generic market insights, first-party data provides a direct connection to individual customer preferences, behaviors, and needs that is unique to each brand.
This granular understanding enables CPG companies to create highly personalized marketing campaigns, optimize product offerings across multiple product lines, and build deeper customer relationships that translate into increased loyalty and lifetime value.
Coca-Cola’s transformation provides perhaps the most compelling example of enterprise-scale data centralization, as the company has implemented an Adobe Customer Data Platform to connect with over two billion customers worldwide across more than 200 countries. This comprehensive data strategy has enabled Coca-Cola to match customers with the most relevant products from their portfolio of over 250 beverages, creating personalized experiences that drive engagement and sales performance.
Unilever has taken a similarly aggressive approach to first-party data ownership, leveraging customer information to deliver personalized experiences that demonstrate deep understanding of consumer habits and preferences.
The company’s strategy focuses on creating meaningful value exchanges with customers. One where consumers receive valuable information that enhances their daily lives in return for sharing personal data. This approach reflects a sophisticated understanding of the reciprocal relationship required for sustainable first-party data collection, moving beyond transactional data gathering to create genuine customer engagement opportunities.
P&G Grooming represents another compelling case study in first-party data strategy evolution, as the company actively seeks partners and technologies to create step-change improvements in data collection capabilities.
Recognizing the limitations of small-scale data acquisition through individual brand websites, P&G is exploring innovative approaches including gaming platforms, metaverse experiences, interactive advertising models, and content hubs to reach millions of consumers simultaneously. This strategic initiative reflects their understanding that competitive advantage requires the data ownership, scale and sophistication necessary to derive meaningful insights from customer interactions.
The Hidden Costs of Agency Data Dependency
The financial and strategic costs of agency data dependency extend far beyond the obvious concerns about vendor lock-in, creating a cascade of inefficiencies that limit brand growth potential. When agencies control critical data assets, brands lose the ability to accurately measure marketing performance across channels, leading to suboptimal budget allocation decisions and missed opportunities for campaign optimization. The fragmented view of customer interactions prevents marketing teams from understanding true attribution patterns. Making it impossible to identify which marketing investments deliver the highest return and which channels are underperforming.
Future-Proofing Your Marketing Operating Model
Future-ready marketing organizations must be designed with flexibility and adaptability at their core. Enabling rapid response to emerging technologies like the metaverse, voice search optimization, new e-commerce platforms, and advanced personalization capabilities. The foundation for this adaptability is comprehensive first-party data ownership that provides the intelligence and agility necessary to navigate an increasingly complex marketing landscape.
The centralization of marketing functions, which has been adopted by 60% of marketing organizations seeking operational efficiency, requires robust data infrastructure. To support unified measurement, planning, and execution across all customer touchpoints.
This centralized approach is only effective when brands maintain direct control over their customer data assets, allowing marketing teams to develop integrated strategies that optimize performance across channels rather than managing fragmented campaigns through multiple agency relationships. The operational efficiency gains from centralization can be substantial, but they require data ownership to realize their full potential.
Strategic Recommendations for CPG Brands
CPG brands seeking to establish data ownership should begin with a comprehensive audit of their current data assets and dependencies, mapping every customer touchpoint, data collection method, and technology integrations. This assessment should include detailed analysis of contract terms, data access rights, and transfer capabilities with existing agency partners. All this to identify immediate risks and opportunities for improvement.
The transition from agency dependency to data ownership should be approached strategically, with careful planning to minimize disruption to ongoing marketing operations while building new capabilities. Brands should consider parallel implementation approaches where new data collection and management systems are built alongside existing agency relationships, allowing for thorough testing and validation before making complete transitions.
Conclusion
The evidence overwhelmingly supports the strategic imperative for CPG brands to take control of their customer data assets rather than remaining dependent on agency-controlled systems that limit growth potential and competitive advantage. As demonstrated by industry leaders like Coca-Cola, Unilever, and P&G, brands that invest in first-party data ownership can achieve superior customer insights, operational efficiency, and strategic flexibility that translate directly into improved marketing performance and business results.
CPG brands that act decisively to establish data ownership will position themselves to capitalize on emerging opportunities while those that delay risk being left behind by competitors who have already made this critical strategic transition. The choice is clear: own your data and control your destiny, or remain dependent and accept the limitations that come with surrendering your most valuable business asset to external partners.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Brand Nest Dispatch by Wandernests— your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
By Wandernests Dispatch – Brand Nest I 12 May, 2025
Pic by pexels.com
The global marketing ecosystem is undergoing a radical transformation. The world’s biggest agency networks—from WPP and Publicis Groupe to consultancies like Accenture Song and Deloitte Digital—are rethinking their structures, portfolios, and strategic priorities.
This isn’t merely a cycle of rebranding or restructuring. What we’re seeing is a consolidation wave that’s reshaping the agency value proposition at its core. The implications for marketing leaders are profound, touching everything from how agency partnerships are structured to what constitutes true marketing ROI in today’s hyper-connected, tech-enabled world.
Why the Consolidation Wave Is Here—and Why It’s Accelerating
CMOs today are navigating fragmented consumer journeys, growing martech stacks, and shrinking budgets. Managing a portfolio of 6–8 specialized agencies—each with different KPIs, processes, and billing structures—is no longer sustainable.
Holding companies are responding with horizontal integration, folding together creative, media, commerce, data, and tech under fewer brands. For example, WPP’s merger of VMLY&R and Wunderman Thompson into a unified “VML” is designed to streamline capabilities and reduce duplication.
The promise? Fewer silos. Faster speed to market. One unified client team.
The most successful marketing campaigns today are no longer linear stories told through TVCs. They’re platform-native ecosystems, optimized in real-time through performance marketing, dynamic creative, and AI-led segmentation.
That requires agencies to integrate deeply not just with media platforms like Meta, Google, and TikTok, but also with client-side systems—CMSs, CDPs, CRM, and analytics stacks.
This is driving a new kind of agency-model-as-a-platform, where tech fluency is as critical as creative genius.
It’s no longer unusual to see Accenture Song, Deloitte Digital, or Bain & Company winning global brand campaigns. What started as a niche expansion into design and customer experience has turned into full-scale competition for creative AOR roles.
These firms are selling end-to-end transformation—from marketing strategy and data infrastructure to CX and content. Their edge? A laser focus on business outcomes, something legacy agencies are still catching up to operationalize.
Accenture Song acquired more than 40 creative and digital agencies worldwide.
Dentsu restructured into four business lines in an effort to unify its acquired brands under a common vision.
However, clients often experience inconsistency in service quality post-M&A. Consolidation on paper doesn’t always translate into integrated delivery on the ground.
So, What Does This Mean for Marketing Clients?
1. Integrated Teams Are the New Table Stakes
Marketers must demand not just multi-capability teams, but multi-disciplinary thinking. It’s not enough to have media, creative, and tech teams in the same building—they must work as one cohesive unit, sharing KPIs and briefs.
Ask your agency how they build cross-functional pods. Do they use shared dashboards? Co-located teams? Joint success metrics?
2. Demand Outcome-Driven Pricing Models
With agencies promising business outcomes, clients must evolve their own procurement approach. Traditional retainers based on hours or deliverables should give way to value-based pricing models—tied to revenue uplift, lead conversions, or brand health metrics.
Some progressive clients are even experimenting with shared risk-reward models, where agencies are bonused for outperforming KPIs and penalized for underperformance.
3. Audit the Talent, Not Just the Credentials
Consolidation often leads to talent churn. As agencies merge, many senior leaders exit, leaving clients with less experienced teams. Don’t be afraid to ask: Who exactly will work on my business? What is their background? Are they permanent or rotating resources?
In the age of consolidation, talent transparency is a must.
4. Agility Beats Scale
Bigger agencies aren’t always better. While consolidation promises integrated delivery, it can also lead to bureaucratic decision-making and slower execution. For some clients, a hybrid model works better: one integrated lead agency complemented by a few niche, agile partners in innovation, performance, or culture.
This requires a modern agency operating model, where a central lead (agency or in-house) orchestrates the whole ecosystem.
The Future Agency: Not One Shape, but Many
So, what will the agency of the future look like?
For some, it will be an embedded pod inside the client’s office, fully integrated into product and business teams.
For others, it may resemble a modular platform model—with strategic services, media execution, data, and content offered as flexible layers.
In high-growth markets, we may see boutique indie agencies specializing in cultural storytelling, winning against legacy giants due to authenticity and agility.
Whatever the form, the successful agency will be one that solves real business problems, not just delivers campaigns.
Final Word: Consolidation Is a Symptom, Not the Solution
What we’re witnessing is not a crisis in the agency world—it’s a necessary evolution. The marketing landscape has changed irreversibly. Brands need partners who can match their speed, understand their tech, and bring creativity to every corner of the customer experience.
Consolidation alone won’t solve that. But it can create the conditions for reinvention—if clients hold their partners to a higher standard.
As a marketing leader, this is your moment to shape the agency ecosystem you truly need. Not one inherited from the past, but one designed for the business realities of today.
Want to talk about how your brand can thrive amid the agency shake-up?
Drop me a message or subscribe to the Wandernests Dispatch for future insights on marketing transformation, creative innovation, and brand strategy.
Craving sharper insights on the brands shaping culture, commerce and marketing? Subscribe to Brand Nest Dispatch by Wandernests— your weekly intel on what’s winning, what’s next, and what it means for marketers who move fast.
